Going down a more serious route for Illusion to have Shadow spells help their school a lot, is to have the spells act more like their PnP 3.5E counterparts.
The change to the spell levels (and addition of Shadow Evocation) should be fine. For two reasons:
These are detailed below:
| Spell Name | Class/Level | School + Max Level | Description | 8 Example Spells | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shadow Conjuration | Bard 4, Sorcerer 4, Wizard 4 | Conjuration, 3 | "Shadow conjuration can mimic any sorcerer or wizard conjuration (summoning) or conjuration (creation) spell of 3rd level or lower." Will save else take 20% of the given effects (eg if damage from Melf's Acid Arrow) and 20% as powerful/last 20% as long. Summoned creatures have 20% of the HP they'd usually have. | Long: Melf's Acid Arrow (Conjuration, 2) Medium: Web (Conjuration, 2) Short: Summon Creature III (Conjuration, 3) Touch: Greater Mage Armor (Conjuration, 3) Personal: Nothing Spare 1: Grease (Conjuration, 2) Spare 2: Mestil's Acid Breath (Conjuration, 3) Spare 3: Flame Arrow (Conjuration, 3) | Not the best spell but has it's uses. Changing to just Conjuration makes sense. |
| Greater Shadow Conjuration | Sorcerer 7, Wizard 7 | Conjuration, 6 | Same as Shadow Conjuration but up to level 6 Conjuration spells, but at 60% effectiveness even if they pass a will save. 60% for HP of summons. | Long: Acid Fog (Conjuration, 6) Medium: Web (Conjuration, 2) Short: Summon Creature VI (Conjuration, 6) Touch: Greater Mage Armor (Conjuration, 3) Personal: Nothing Spare 1: Grease (Conjuration, 2) Spare 2: Mestil's Acid Breath (Conjuration, 3) Spare 3: Flame Arrow (Conjuration, 3) | Much more powerful at 60% effect even if saved. |
| Shades | Sorcerer 9, Wizard 9 | Conjuration, 8 | Same as Shadow Conjuration but up to level 8 Conjuration spells, but at 80% effectiveness even if they pass a will save. 80% for HP of summons. | Long: Acid Fog (Conjuration, 6) Medium: Web (Conjuration, 2) Short: Summon Creature VIII (Conjuration, 8) Touch: Greater Mage Armor (Conjuration, 3) Personal: Nothing Spare 1: Greater Planar Binding (Conjuration, 8) Spare 2: Web (Conjuration, 2) Spare 3: Mestil's Acid Breath (Conjuration, 3) | Very effective even if saved can get also any level 8 or under conjuration spell. Needs really some additional spells here but the advantage of having lower level spells in this spell is they get the illusion save DC and spell level of 8 against them (eg Web becomes more powerful). |
| Shadow Evocation | Bard 5, Sorcerer 5, Wizard 5 | Evocation 4 | "You tap energy from the Plane of Shadow to cast a quasi-real, illusory version of a sorcerer or wizard evocation spell of 4th level or lower." Will save else take 20% of the given effects of damage, 20% as powerful etc. Gust of Wind or similar "non-effect" driven spells are always at full power. | Long: Ice Storm (Evocation, 4) Medium: Wall of Fire (Evocation, 4) Short: Gedlee's Electric Loop (Evocation, 2) Touch: Flame Weapon (Evocation, 2) Personal: Elemental Shield (Evocation, 4) Spare 1: Fireball (Evocation, 3) Spare 2: Scintillating Sphere (Evocation, 3) Spare 3: Lightning Bolt (Evocation, 3) | Evocation only spells get the extra save DC and illusion spell school helping illusionists out with damage. |
| Greater Shadow Evocation | Sorcerer 8, Wizard 8 | Evocation 7 | Same as Shadow Evocation but up to level 7 spells at 60% effectiveness. | Long: Chain Lightning (Evocation, 6) Medium: Great Thunderclap (Evocation, 7) Short: Prismatic spray (Evocation, 7) Touch: Flame Weapon (Evocation, 2) Personal: Elemental Shield (Evocation, 4) Spare 1: Delayed Blast Fireball - 1 Round (Evocation, 7) Spare 2: Cone of Cold (Evocation, 5) Spare 3: Ball Lightning (Evocation, 5) | A lot more effective at 60% power of the original spell. |
The problem with the current method of 8 set spells is figuring out what a good set of spells to use for those 8 slots are. It becomes also redundant when you can have nice NUI spell selectors and more spells are added later!
The main problem with having slots you can choose is is an issue of text, since we can have SetTextureOverride apply a new spell icon to a given subspell icon. SetTlkOverride does work but conflicts if another caster changes theirs (NPCs can do whatever too but this can be set/set back pretty much on the timing of casting). This might be enough to be honest?
We could also mix it up and have these:
Sadly we don't have 10 slots since we could do "area" and "targeted" for each. For now we'll just have to have every single target be valid and add additional validation in the shadow spell script.
For the spell data we can have some nice "illusion-ary" VFX and SFX used for conjuration and casting. We then do more magic in the spell script:
The key effects are to reduce the effectiveness if a (separate) Will save is successful:
3 spells in this range:
These provide access to 4 normal spells and a unique "Summon Shadow" spell.
One advantage of this spell is having five spells combined into one. For sorcerers, this effectively increases the number of spells known. For wizards, this provides the ability to select which spell to cast at the time of casting.
The main issue is they were not as flexible as the spells they were based off (which could mimic loads more spells), but they did have the benefit of having the full effects of the real spells.
Some ideas on what to do. We can at least expand them by 3 with more subdial options. The spells are considered pretty weak, and I'd agree, with the levels of the spells allowed quite a lot lower then the spell slot - I mean who would want to cast a random Magic Missile in a 4th level spell slot? Bioware may have done this to avoid the "20% power" stuff however, but then again you get access to Cone of Cold for Shades, one a level lower and thus could be considerably more useful (and gains a save DC bonus).
Keeping the originals would keep both some backwards compatibility, some sensible things for AI's to use, and doesn't mess with things too much.
The defaults are:
| Spell | Spell Level | Subspells | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shadow Conjuration | 4 | Darkness (Evocation, 2) Invisibility (Illusion, 2) Mage Armor (Conjuration, 1) Magic Missile (Evocation, 1) Summon Shadow | SRD: https://www.dandwiki.com/wiki/3e_SRD:Shadow_Conjuration Essentially 20% power of spells level 3 or lower. |
| Greater Shadow Conjuration | 5 | Melf's Acid Arrow (Conjuration, 2) Ghostly Visage (Illusion, 2) Web (Conjuration, 2) Minor Globe of Invulnerability (Abjuration, 4) Summon Shadow | SRD: https://www.dandwiki.com/wiki/3e_SRD:Shadow_Conjuration,_Greater Essentially 40% power of spells level 4 or lower. |
| Shades | 6 | Cone of Cold (Evocation, 5) Fireball (Evocation, 3) Stoneskin (Abjuration, 4) Wall of Fire (Evocation, 4) Summon Shadow | SRD: https://www.dandwiki.com/wiki/3e_SRD:Shades Essentially 60% power of spells level 5 or lower. |
Fixes
| Name | Changes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
All base spells | Added Quicken to Shadow Conjuration and Greater Shadow Conjuration | On Metamagic: need to think how best we can do this, maybe just allow all metamagic (as appropriate) and hey if it doesn't work for that particular spell no loss. Improves the spell versatility. |
All subspells | All spell schools set to Illusion (for Arcane Defence, Spell Focus) All components fixed to parent spell (don't think any are wrong, all stomatic/verbal) All levels set to parent spell (save DCs) Metamagic matches parents (adding Quicken generally) Fixed any hostile settings as needed (eg; Shades, Wall of Fire) | This helps illusionist casters a bit with spell DCs |
Shadow Conjuration - Summon Shadow Greater Shadow Conjuration - Summon Shadow Shades - Summon Shadow | AI Category changed to Summoning Hostile setting set to "No" Fixed level settings (counterspell/spellcraft) of all subspells to match the parent spell | The wrong AI and hostility rating implies it was a different spell in the 5th slot at one point (and this one was originally going to be a level 5 Cleric spell, weird!) |
Options here:
Since we can't link to existing Spell ID lines we need to add new ones.
Any spell would be best done if we can fake the spell ID (insert complicated system using TagEffect here...!), or only allow instant spells - eg Fireball or the like that do damage not persistent effects (There's no saved effects to interact with then).
Some ideas if we were to pre-set them. A focus would be on areas missing from the other 4 in that spell already. No summons since we have Summon Shadow.
| Spell | Spell Level | Maximum spell level | Additional Subspell Ideas | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shadow Conjuration | 4 | 3 | Negative Energy Burst (Necromancy, 3) Blindness/Deafness (Enchantment, 2) Flame weapon (Evocation, 2) | Existing: No AOE spells, all existing ones are levels 1 and 2 |
| Greater Shadow Conjuration | 5 | 4 | Enervation (Necromancy, 4) Confusion (Enchantment, 4) Isaac's lesser missile storm (Evocation, 4) | Existing: Good variety of spells already (defensive, offensive) levels 2 or 4 |
| Shades | 6 | 5 | Hold Monster (Enchantment, 5) Lesser Spell Mantle (Abjuration, 5) Bigby's interposing hand (Evocation, 5) | Existing: Quite a lot of fire! AOE explosions, persistent spells and Stoneskin is good. Levels 3, 4, 5. |